
Are Public Executions Biblical?
Someone asked me whether I agree with pastors who argue that executions in the Bible were public and that we may therefore encourage the state to livestream capital punishment.
I wrote these lines as a personal reflection, but I would love to offer them in humility and remain open to correction from my brothers.
I answer that the legitimacy of a punishment does not establish the moral legitimacy of every manner in which that punishment is administered or presented to the public.
For the sake of this argument, let us grant that the Old Testament indications of capital punishment can be a legitimate form of civil justice today. Let us also grant that the state may have good reasons to announce an execution and inform the public that it has taken place. It does not follow, however, that the execution itself should become a public event. This easily can turn into a public spectacle through livestreaming or pay-per-view broadcasts. Informing the public about an act of justice is not the same as inviting people to watch a human being die by firing squad.
John Calvin, while defending the legitimacy of civil punishment, warns against “unseasonable severity” in its administration. For Calvin, a just tribunal is also “presided over by mercy” (IRC, IV.20.10). He further insists that magistrates must not be “borne headlong by anger, nor hurried away by hatred, nor burn with implacable severity.” Calvin stands on the shoulders of a giant such as Augustine, citing him to show that magistrates “even pity a common nature in him in whom they punish an individual fault” (IV.20.11). These warnings are worth remembering when we consider not only the legitimacy of punishment, but also the manner in which it is administered and presented to the public.
I find it troubling that pastors in this land offer justifications for this kind of public display without adequately considering its moral implications. I have also seen, alongside this theological reasoning, a growing excitement among some people to return to this type of public execution—remember that the last one occurred in 1936 during the Jim Crow era.
A country’s moral dignity is reflected not only in its willingness to punish wrongdoing, but also in the restraint with which it exercises its power. A society may retain its commitment to law and punishment while diminishing its own moral character through the manner in which it exercises and displays that power.
This concern becomes especially important in the current climate of conflict, in which a growing number of theologians, pastors, and other public voices speak against empathy, considering it a form of wimpiness or weakness. I understand that emotional identification with another person’s suffering should not require us to deny wrongdoing, abandon truth, or oppose just punishment. Yet the rhetoric and emphasis of these voices deserve careful examination, especially when warnings against misplaced empathy seem to receive greater attention than the dangers of callousness, vindictiveness, and the corruption of our moral sensibilities.
We also hear similar attitudes expressed by military leaders and ordinary citizens. This deserves particular attention when considered alongside contemporary proposals to make executions publicly viewable. I am not suggesting that criticism of misplaced empathy necessarily leads to support for livestreamed executions. Rather, I am asking whether this emphasis on severity, without sufficient attention to compassion and moral restraint, may contribute to a climate in which the public display of punishment receives more attention than the moral limits governing its exercise.
Ideas can shape moral dispositions in ways their advocates may not anticipate. Public intellectuals and religious leaders therefore have reason to consider not only whether their arguments are defensible in theory, but also how their rhetoric might influence habits of judgment and conduct in practice.
The language we use about enemies, authority, and the exercise of power shapes how we regard the humanity (imago Dei) of those toward whom force is directed. It is therefore worth asking whether certain prevailing attitudes toward strength and severity might make it harder to reflect on the moral limits of force and the responsibilities that accompany its use.
Consider, for instance, the theonomists who years ago declared, “We want a magistrate to begin hanging violent criminals from a tall tree.” Some of them now see this moment as an opportunity to repeat the biblical justification for public executions. They may say they welcome the government’s proposal so long as it does not create a “ghoulish atmosphere.” But I find this reasoning insufficiently persuasive: it acknowledges the danger of turning executions into spectacles without adequately explaining how making them public can be reconciled with preventing precisely that outcome.
There is also a particular irony in this danger for those who identify with the Reformed tradition, and some of these theonomists, indeed they do. The doctrine of total depravity affirms that the Fall has corrupted every faculty of the human person—mind, will, and affections—so that even our best judgments remain susceptible to distortion by sin. Consequently, when we believe we are defending justice, we must remember that our motives may still be mingled with pride, vindictiveness, cruelty, or self-deception. How can we prevent unbelievers from developing even more degrading internal feelings regarding the viewing of executions? The reality of indwelling sin calls us to humility and caution, reminding us that the sincerity of our convictions does not guarantee the purity of our intentions.
This principle applies both to those who advocate severe punishment and to those who oppose it. None of us should presume that our moral judgments are entirely free from the effects of sin. The doctrine of total depravity does not require us to abandon the pursuit of justice; nor undermine the legitimacy or usefulness of civil authority. Rather, it requires us to pursue justice with a sober awareness of our own moral limitations.
Further, people who observe these types of pastors’ rhetoric may come to associate the Reformed faith, or Reformed ministry more generally, with support for indifference and callousness and the call for public executions today, ignoring important applications of the Imago Dei and the doctrine of total depravity. I hope more Reformed pastors speak up when influential voices risk presenting a distorted account of the Reformed faith before the world. We must defend the legitimacy of civil punishment while remaining attentive to the dangers of vindictiveness and indifference to human suffering. Otherwise, we risk presenting a distorted account of biblical punitive justice: one that emphasizes the legitimacy of punishment while giving insufficient attention to the moral restraints governing its exercise.
I love America, and I want our country to preserve its moral dignity in the way it administers justice. As Proverbs reminds us, ‘by steadfast love his throne is upheld’ (Proverbs 20:28). If the rest of the world promotes indecent means of administering justice, we as Americans must press on, administering justice humanely and without sensationalism. The question is not simply whether we punish the guilty, but whether our understanding and practice of justice remain governed by the moral wisdom Scripture requires.
Here, writing from a corner of the church, your unprofitable brother William, always ready to listen to you.





























