
Everyone’s in a Huff
I first heard of Wes Huff when he was interviewed on the Joe Rogan podcast. I was pleasantly surprised to see a fellow Canadian attempting to defend the Christian faith to such an audience.
I was also a bit surprised because I’d never heard of him before. It turns out he didn’t really have any significant credentials or publications. He is currently pursuing PhD studies at the University of Toronto (Wycliffe College), though even this pursuit may be terminated soon by the University.
How does one at such a young age (33) get to a position where they are on a show with the reach of Joe Rogan as a Christian apologist? How does one get over a million YouTube subscribers as a Christian thinker?
Turns out, Wes had done a lot of writing and speaking.
Turns out, also, that if something is too good to be true…
The apparent citation problems in his work reveal – at least to me – a young scholar-in-training who clearly didn’t have sufficient expertise to be discoursing on so many complex topics. He was too immature, careless, and insecure in his own expertise to be at the level many imagined him to be. It all happened so quickly, and now it has, overnight, spectacularly backfired.
The responses are predictably polarizing. Some have seen this as a nothing-burger and have already offered “not guilty” verdicts. These are people who ostensibly have little understanding of academic integrity on a scholarly level. They believed the first narrative – put out by Wes, mind you – that this was just some sloppy work as a student ten years ago that has little relevance today. But Wes is attempting to be a scholar and, as such, must be judged according to accepted scholarly standards. There is a big difference between a YouTube personality with some ability to defend the faith and a bona fide scholar. He may be equipped to be the former, but he certainly does not seem to be anywhere close to the latter.
Others think he should lose his MTS degree, academic career, PhD student status, and be consigned to the seventh circle of hell. They might not admit to that latter part, but they seem particularly giddy at these recent revelations.
From the evidence I’ve seen, things are looking (by the hour) increasingly bleak for Wes. The worrying thing for me is the pattern of plagiarism. Those who write a lot can all make a mistake here and there on citations; they can be a bit lazy or even unintentionally plagiarize. Human laziness can rear its ugly head even among the best scholars. But there are some cases where patterns start to emerge and those are the cases that need to be taken seriously because they can reveal something more sinister in the heart.
Before evangelicals start declaring his innocence, they should pause and consider the evidence. There are many from other traditions who not only want to see Wes fail and fall, but they want more reasons to hurl invectives at Evangelicals for their lack of honesty, scholarship, and thoughtfulness. To the degree that some blindly justify Wes’s work, they are proving themselves to be unserious thinkers and possessing different moral standards for their friends compared to their opponents.
His second public statement on taking the concerns about plagiarism in his work seriously reads, as my Facebook Messenger friend said, like “HR bureaucratic speech”. This was in addition to a sort of “half-baked” video canceling his younger self, which also unnecessarily involved another pastor who, it seems, really shouldn’t have had to publicly vouch for Wes.
Whatever Wes does in his next (third!) public statement, I think there needs to be ownership of his sin in a clear and unambiguous way. It will be painful, but in the long run it will be better for him and his soul (Prov. 28:13). His supporters should stop making this worse by trying to convince him (and us) he’s largely innocent. Of course, only Wes knows what was going on in his heart when he did his work, but we can only look at the troubling evidence. We can become intoxicated in our pride, which keeps us from seeing things clearly. For those who ascend to prominence, they can easily believe that different rules apply to them. In this case, it seems to be one rule for me, and another for thee.
Make no mistake, expertise takes a long, long time. The emergence of Wes Huff seemed sudden and rapid. The current allegations and evidence make it seem like he got to the place he’s at sort of unfairly. There’s a cautionary tale here. If shortcuts are taken, you may end up paying a much greater price than if you had been more patient. As they say, the shortcut is always the long road.
You might get away with any sin for a period, but it usually finds you out. This can be a mercy from God if we respond according to biblical, not worldly, principles (Ps. 32).
Perhaps this will be for Wes’s long-term good. God has providentially allowed this for numerous reasons. Many who have gained fame have come crashing down because of the so-called heights they ascended without a stable foundation. I worry that such a fall can lead to bitterness or denial from many involved, including Wes.
For those who have a certain antagonism towards Wes, they should remember not to rejoice when your enemy falls (Prov. 24:17). He has been foolish, but don’t become a fool, too.
Love believes all things and hopes all things; I want to believe he’s been immature and foolish, not devious and vainglorious. I still would like to believe the former, but depending on how he handles this, I may be tempted to believe the latter.
The truth will set him free, even if that freedom comes at the expense of his own glory. This not only goes for Wes, but for all of us.





























